Why I hate the ‘clean eating’ concept

by Mary C. Weaver, CSCS, M.S. on January 22, 2012

berries

It’s all the rage to speak of “clean eating.” We’ve got cookbooks, magazine series, and blogs devoted to the topic. So what could be wrong with the idea of eating clean? Plenty.

It encourages food obsession.

If some food is clean, with that word’s connotations of purity, goodness, and virtue, other food must be dirty, unclean, impure, and vile.

Is that rational talk? Does it even make sense?

No and no.

No, it’s not rational because it assigns moral virtues to food. And by extension, it encourages us to think that we are virtuous and good by eating “clean.” So if we’ve sworn we’ll eat clean and then we go out and enjoy burritos and beer (I’m assuming they qualify as dirty), doesn’t that mean we’ve fallen from grace and become unclean?

Women have enough food issues without that sort of sophistry.

No, it doesn’t make sense because [click to continue…]

{ 10 comments }

Fit into forty: introduction

by sarah on January 21, 2012

Sarah's Fit into forty series

Mary here: Let me introduce you to my friend Sarah. Sarah, meet the PrimeFit crew. Crew, meet Sarah. Sarah, take it away!

2012 is a year of change for me. I’ll be 40 in November, and I am determined to be fit. Not fitter. Fit.

I have always been an active person, but after a severe bout of postnatal depression, I lost the urge to move about and gained the urge to stuff my face with food. I was fortunate enough to be able to afford bigger clothes every few weeks-until a week after my 39th birthday, I realized I had a wardrobe full of tracksuit bottoms, and I had become, for want of a better word, a slob.

The big event.

I realized that I needed to lose 9 stone (approximately 100 pounds) to be anywhere near fighting fit, and it hurt. It hurt the kind of pain only a Krispy Kreme can cure. I have a landmark-my daughter’s 18th birthday. I want to be a UK size 12 (US 16), and I want to look good in the family photos of the big event. I don’t want to look like I do now.

Fit into forty.

I know Mary from a few places online, and we have had some incredible conversations and one of them evolved from dieting alone. I say you can diet on your own, do exercise and get fit. Mary disagrees, and all her qualifications and experience mean nothing, because let’s face it, my willpower is stronger than Mary’s expertise I have a weird sense of humour, but I am sure we’ll get used to each other.

[click to continue…]

{ 10 comments }

Is your diet endangering your muscles?

January 7, 2012
Thumbnail image for Is your diet endangering your muscles?

Bad news for overeaters who prefer their treats in the form of carbs and fat (cake, French fries, and chips come to mind). And good news for those who’d rather indulge with a nice steak. Last week a fascinating study, published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, reported what had happened to the [...]

Read the full article →

What would you rather be—strong or skinny?

January 5, 2012
Thumbnail image for What would you rather be—strong or skinny?

If I asked you to shout out–quick!–one word that summarizes your body goals, what would it be? You might say healthy, lively, or energetic. You might say fit, sexy, or muscular. You could say just about anything, and I’d be fine with it. But if your answer is skinny, I have a problem. Maybe it’s just [...]

Read the full article →

Why you can keep the weight off

December 31, 2011
Thumbnail image for Why you can keep the weight off

If you want to be discouraged about losing fat and keeping it off, by all means read “The Fat Trap,” published in The New York Times Magazine on Dec. 28. If you’re curious, here’s the link. The article—very well-written, by the way—summarizes the thinking of a number of scientists who believe the evidence indicates that [...]

Read the full article →

Coping with trigger foods

December 20, 2011
Thumbnail image for Coping with trigger foods

Question: When does 500 calories not fill you up? Answer: When it’s 500 calories of your favorite trigger foods. Yesterday the administrative assistants at my office had a cookie swap. (How come nobody ever has a fruit swap?) It was certainly not because there has been any lack of sweets at work. For weeks I’ve [...]

Read the full article →

Survival tips for holiday parties

December 17, 2011
Thumbnail image for Survival tips for holiday parties

Most Americans gain close to a pound every year during the holiday season. That doesn’t sound like much, but after 10 or 20 years of putting on a pound a year, you end up in clothes one or two sizes larger. I’ve put together some survival strategies to help you minimize the damage, and you [...]

Read the full article →

Squeeze more exercise into less time

December 17, 2011
Thumbnail image for Squeeze more exercise into less time

Quick—what’s the No. 1 reason you either don’t exercise or don’t log as many workouts as you’d like? Most women I know will say “not enough time!” I say it too. We’re all overscheduled, with so many more commitments than our calendars can hold. But here’s yet another study (among many) suggesting that brief, intense [...]

Read the full article →

Defeating weight-loss lies with truth

December 5, 2011
Thumbnail image for Defeating weight-loss lies with truth

Kudos to Leigh (@bookieboo) of Mamavation for proposing that bloggers write today about “what they think is wrong with the health/fitness industry and what they think can be changed.” What’s wrong with the health and fitness industry? I could name a whole lot of things that irritate me, but today I’m going to focus on [...]

Read the full article →

Popular diets, part 3: paleo

December 2, 2011
Thumbnail image for Popular diets, part 3: paleo

Because friends have asked me to comment on the paleo diet, I’ve decided to stick my neck out. I’m hesitant, though, because some people’s approach to paleo approaches religious fervor—and when we’re not talking about actual religion, that always makes me a little nervous. The comment box should be interesting . . . So here [...]

Read the full article →